Best insurance companies in Madison, WI

We figured out the best insurance companies to work for in Wisconsin using data on salaries, company financial health, and employee diversity. You can also search for the best insurance companies to work for in any other state or city.

Best Companies To Work For In Madison, WI
  1. Zippia Score 4.6

    #1 Best insurance company in Madison
    Company Description:

    Find affordable health insurance coverage for yourself, your family and your employees all from Dean Health Plan.

  2. Zippia Score 4.5

    #2 Best insurance company in Madison
    Company Description:

    For more than 85 years, American Family Insurance has built its reputation on sound principles. We strive to provide you industry-leading service, exceptional claims experience and products that build long-term relationships. This is accomplished by treating policyholders fairly in a helpful and caring way and making it easy and convenient to work with us. We know our customers like family. American Family Insurance thrives by conducting its business in accordance with the highest ethical standards and the law at all times. Integrity is part of our culture and always has been. The reputation we enjoy and trust-based relationships we have built with our customers are determined by the example set by management and the character and good judgment exercised at all levels of our organization. It's a way of doing business that our customers have come to expect from us and a standard that we continue to live up to.

    Show More
    What people like about American Family Insurance:

    Diversity & Inclusion are high priorities in our company. Community outreach is how we give back. Premiums mean something more than profits.

  3. Zippia Score 4.4

    #3 Best insurance company in Madison
    Company Description:

    Wisconsin Physicians Service Insurance Corporation is a not-for-profit service insurance corporation based in Madison, Wisconsin. WPS offers health insurance plans for groups and individuals and benefit plan administration for businesses.

    Show More
    What people like about Wps Health Insurance:

    Working from home, lots of flexibility in the schedule. Minimal stress

  4. Zippia Score 4.2

    #4 Best insurance company in Madison
  5. Zippia Score 4.1

    #5 Best insurance company in Madison
    Company Description:

    Wisconsin Reinsurance Corporation offers property/casualty reinsurance coverage and services for mutual insurance companies. Its product lines include homeowners, farmowners, and commercial policies. The company's WRC Agency division provides brokerage services, and Wisconsin Adjusting Service offers liability claims adjustment services. Other subsidiaries include WRC Systems (software for insurers) and 1st Auto & Casualty (personal and farm automobile policies). In addition to serving insurers in Wisconsin, the company is active in Arkansas, Iowa, and South Dakota. Wisconsin Reinsurance Corporation was founded in 1931.

    Show More
  6. Job type you want
    Full Time
    Part Time
    Internship
    Temporary
  7. Zippia Score 4.1

    Company Description:

    CUNA Mutual Investment Corporation is a holding company. The company, through its subsidiaries, provides life insurance, financial services, and brokerage services to credit unions. The company was founded in 1972 and is based in Madison, Wisconsin. CUNA Mutual Investment Corporation operates as a subsidiary of CMFG Life Insurance Company.

    Show More
  8. Zippia Score 3.9

    Company Description:

    M3 handles the insurance, employee benefits, and risk management needs of clients across a wide array of industries.

  9. Zippia Score 3.7

    Company Mission Statement:

    To help you strengthen your workforce.

  10. Zippia Score 3.7

    Company Description:

    4Home has developed an XML-based software and services platform that OEM hardware vendors and service providers can use to deliver compelling applications and services into the connected home. 4Home's suite of solutions allows users to automate almost any application they want: remotely monitor their homes, get Web-based content on the TV, control home systems from their mobile phones, control all home devices and digital media in one unified user-interface, and track their home energy usage down to the device level. The company feels that "home control services" are the next suite of services to be offered by major broadband providers (after the trifecta of voice, video, and data), and consists of home monitoring, media

    Show More
  11. Zippia Score 3.7

    Company Description:

    Hausmann Group is a full-service independent Wisconsin insurance agency providing business services and insurance in Milwaukee and Madison.

  12. Zippia Score 3.6

    Company Description:

    National Mutual Benefit makes a special point to be active in the communities where their members live. Every member is geographically separated into branches that are the focal point of NMB's charitable mission. NMB utilizes internal funds to manage, promote, and assist these branches in completing charitable work in their communities. They are a not-for-profit fraternal benefit society that offers life insurance and annuity products. As a fraternal benefit society, National Mutual Benefit is classified as a 501(c)(8) tax-exempt organization that must organize its members into social lodges called branches. They are a not-for-profit fraternal benefit society that offers life insurance and annuity products. As a fraternal benefit society, National Mutual Benefit is classified as a 501(c)(8) tax-exempt organization that must organize its members into social lodges called branches.

    Show More
  13. Zippia Score 3.5

    Company Description:

    Since 1910, National Guardian Life has consistently been rated one of America's most successful independent mutual life insurance companies. While adhering to the highest standards of quality and integrity, NGL continually demonstrates its commitment t...

    Show More
  14. Zippia Score 3.2

    Company Description:

    WEA Trust offers high-quality, flexible health insurance plans for Wisconsin employers. Dental insurance and vision coverage options also available.

  15. Zippia Score 3.1

    Company Description:

    Rural Mutual Insurance Company offers property and casualty insurance services. It offers agriculture and farm insurance, including farm buildings, vehicles, farms personal property, and workers compensation; personal auto insurance, including liability, collision, transportation expenses, and rental reimbursement; business insurance, including buildings, business property extensions, business auto insurance, collision coverage, and other comprehensive coverage; home insurance, condominiums or apartments, including renters, watercraft, equipment breakdown, recreational vehicles, and builder's risk; life insurance, including long term care, and disability income; and medicare supplements.

    Show More

Other national companies with offices in Madison, WI

Zippia Score 4.8

Company Description:

The Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) preserves and promotes public confidence in the U.S. financial system by insuring depositors for at least $250,000 per insured bank; by identifying, monitoring and addressing risks to the deposit insurance funds; and by limiting the effect on the economy and the financial system when a bank or thrift institution fails. The FDIC Board of Directors is comprised of a chairman, vice chairman and FDIC director, as well as the Comptroller of the Currency and the head of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. The FDIC publishes their budget, strategic plans, and financial reports on an annual or quarterly basis. The Annual Reports page contains the yearly accomplishments of the corporation, and has each report available from 1996 to the present. FDIC runs and office of international affairs, considering technical assistance programs, foreign visitor and secondment programs, foreign examiner training programs, international leadership development programs, and FDIC subject matter experts participate as keynote speakers, panel members and facilitators for numerous international organizations' conferences, symposia and seminars. The FDIC was established in 1933 in response to the thousands of bank failures that occurred in the 1920s and early 1930s.

Show More
What people like about Federal Deposit Insurance:

Work with very smart people, great facilities, good pay and great benefits.

Zippia Score 4.8

Company Description:

RLI is a specialty insurance company that offers a diversified portfolio of property and casualty coverages and surety bonds serving niche or underserved markets. We combine profitable underwriting, solid investment returns and effective capital management to deliver consistent, long-term growth in shareholder value. RLI has more than 850 employees in 50 locations across the United States. At RLI, our talent distinguishes us and that makes us different. We hire smart people, including the best underwriters in the business, and then give them the resources and freedom to drive profitable growth. Our niche, market-driven products exceed customer expectations; satisfying demands where other insurance companies do not compete. Our vision for the future is to remain focused on building and managing a portfolio of innovative products and solutions that meet and surpass the expectations of shareholders

Show More

Zippia Score 4.7

Company Description:

United Fire Group sells through more than 1,000 independent agencies in 43 states, plus the District of Columbia, and as a life insurer in 36 states, represented by more than 900 independent life agencies. They employ more than 900 individuals throughout their offices in California, Colorado, Iowa (home office), Louisiana, New Jersey, Pennsylvania and Texas.

Show More

Zippia Score 4.7

Company Description:

MEDICA is a French private health group operating care facilities for dependent persons.

Zippia Score 4.7

Company Description:

Ameritas Life Insurance - offers a wide range of insurance and financial products and services to individuals, families and busineses

Zippia Score 4.6

Company Description:

ExamWorks Group, Inc. is a provider of independent medical examinations, peer reviews, bill reviews, Medicare compliance, case management, record retrieval, document management and other related services (“IME services”). We provide the majority of these IME services through our medical panel of credentialed physicians and other medical providers. Our clients include property and casualty insurance carriers, law firms, third- party claim administrators and government agencies that use independent services to confirm the veracity of claims by sick or injured individuals and to facilitate the delivery and quality of cost-effective care for workers' compensation, automotive, personal injury liability and disability insurance coverage. We help our clients manage costs and enhance their risk management and compliance processes by verifying the validity, nature, cause and extent of claims, identifying fraud and providing fast, efficient and quality IME services.

Show More

Zippia Score 4.4

Company Description:

Wisconsin Physicians Service Insurance Corporation is a not-for-profit service insurance corporation based in Madison, Wisconsin. WPS offers health insurance plans for groups and individuals and benefit plan administration for businesses.

Show More
What people like about Wps Health Insurance:

Working from home, lots of flexibility in the schedule. Minimal stress

Zippia Score 4.3

Company Description:

Quartz is a health plan services company. The company manages the nationally recognized provider-sponsored health insurance plans - Gundersen Health Plan and Unity Health Insurance, which are co-owned by Gundersen Health System and UW Health. As a thir...

Show More

Zippia Score 4.3

Company Description:

Auto-Owners Insurance is the largest property and casualty insurance company domiciled in Michigan. Auto-Owners success can be traced back from its present management to the early leadership of Vern V. Moulton who, in 1916, organized Auto-Owners Insurance Company in Mt. Pleasant, Michigan. The infant Company had no capital and was housed in one room of a bank building. Auto-Owners operated in Mt. Pleasant for a little less than a year. In 1917, V.V. Moulton literally picked the Company up, placed it under his arm and in his pocket (the Company consisted of one book of policyholders' names and $174.25 in assets), and moved Auto-Owners to Lansing, Michigan. It wasn't long before the Depression began, and Auto-Owners weathered even the lowest point of that era - the bank holidays of February 1933. The Company demonstrated its corporate toughness and financial stability by paying all claims promptly, daily, and IN CASH! The firm was then writing more than $2.5 million in insurance premiums. Auto-Owners entered the general casualty insurance field in 1940, having previously written only automobile insurance. During the next five years, the Company found it necessary to acquire three more buildings in the vicinity of its main office to accommodate its continued growth. In 1951 it consolidated all of its offices into one home office, which was constructed in downtown Lansing.

Show More

Zippia Score 4.2

Company Description:

Church Mutual is the leading insurer of religious organizations and a premier insurance provider for other organizations that inspire and serve others.

Zippia Score 4.1

Company Description:

At Holmes Murphy, they pride themselves on selling “thinking”, not insurance. In a nutshell, they sell the cumulative knowledge and experience that make insurance and businesses work better. It's a philosophy that's worked for them since their inception more than 85 years ago. As an independent brokerage, they serve business and industry leaders across the nation in the areas of property-casualty insurance, employee benefits, captive insurance, risk management and loss control.

Show More

Zippia Score 4.0

Company Description:

Sentry Insurance was founded in 1904 by members of the Wisconsin Retail Hardware Association to provide quality insurance for its members. Throughout their more than 100-year history, They've protected businesses, families and individuals with Strength, Protection and Vigilance.

Show More
What people like about Sentry:

The Associates are great to work with as well as the overall structure of the company.

Zippia Score 3.9

Company Description:

LTCI Partners is a national brokerage firm specializing in long-term care (LTC) insurance solutions.

Zippia Score 3.9

Company Description:

McClone is a Wisconsin-based risk management partner focused on providing businesses with insurance, employee benefits consultation, HR services, business continuity services and more.

Show More

Zippia Score 3.7

Company Mission Statement:

The Oklahoma Insurance Department will provide competent and trustworthy employees who will protect Oklahoma consumers by providing timely assistance and information and efficiently regulate the insurance industry's market behavior and financial solvency while fostering a competitive insurance marketplace.

Show More

Best insurance companies in Madison, WI

RankCompanyZippia Score
1Dean Health Plan4.6
2American Family Insurance4.5
3Wps Health Insurance4.4
4Physicians Plus Insurance Corporation4.2
5Wisconsin Reinsurance Corporation4.1
6CUNA Mutual Investment Corporation4.1
7M3 Insurance3.9
8Madison National Life Insurance3.7
9eflexgroup3.7
10MyHaus3.7
11BetterLife3.6
12Preneed Reinsurance Co-America3.5
13Wisconsin Education Association3.2
14Rural Mutual Insurance3.1