Best insurance companies in Columbus, OH

We figured out the best insurance companies to work for in Ohio using data on salaries, company financial health, and employee diversity. You can also search for the best insurance companies to work for in any other state or city.

Best Companies To Work For In Columbus, OH
  1. Zippia Score 4.8

    #1 Best insurance company in Columbus
    Company Description:

    In 1921, State Automobile Mutual Insurance Company was founded. With three employees and a rented room in downtown Columbus, Ohio, Bob Pein set forth to tackle the inequities in the insurance industry. From the very beginning, State Auto advocated the independent agency system as the best approach to serving the needs of its policyholders. To this day, as hometown neighbors, local independent agents continue to provide efficient, professional and more personalized service than that of their competitors.

    Show More
  2. Zippia Score 4.8

    #2 Best insurance company in Columbus
    Company Description:

    Root Insurance is a property-casualty insurtech that offers personalized, affordable coverage in an app. Using technology in smartphones to measure driving behavior such as braking, speed of turns, driving times, and route regularity, Root determines who is a safe driver and who isn't. By only insuring safe drivers, Root can offer more affordable car insurance rates. Root also offers hassle-free and affordable app-based renters insurance, providing coverage that's easy to understand and is personalized around real consumer needs.

    Show More
  3. Zippia Score 4.7

    #3 Best insurance company in Columbus
    Company Description:

    Motorists Mutual Insurance Company writes personal and commercial insurance lines primarily in Indiana, Kentucky, Michigan, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and West Virginia. The company offers personal insurance products, such as automobile, homeowners, condo owners, renters, umbrella, identity theft, and recreational vehicle, as well as life, health, and retirement insurance; and commercial insurance, including business owners, contractors, property, garage, employment e-Source, and employment practices liability insurance. It also provides claims processing services for commercial automotive, property, and liability; and personal automotive, homeowners, and auto glass insurance, as well as workers compensation. In addition, the company provides risk management services. It offers its products through a network of agents. The company was founded in 1928 and is based in Columbus, Ohio. It has additional offices in Akron, Cincinnati, Cleveland, Columbus, and Dayton, Ohio; and Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Motorists Mutual Insurance Company operates as a subsidiary of The Motorists Insurance Group, Inc.

    Show More
  4. Zippia Score 4.4

    #4 Best insurance company in Columbus
    Company Description:

    Safe Auto Insurance Company is a property and casualty auto insurance carrier.

  5. Zippia Score 4.3

    #5 Best insurance company in Columbus
    Company Description:

    Safelite Solutions, LLC provides auto glass and related claim solutions to insurance and fleet companies in the United States. It offers property and casualty claims management services. The company was founded in 2003 and is based in Columbus, Ohio. Safelite Solutions, LLC operates as a subsidiary of Belron US, Inc.

    Show More
  6. Job type you want
    Full Time
    Part Time
    Internship
    Temporary
  7. Zippia Score 4.1

    Company Description:

    Agents primarily representing one or more insurance carriers, or brokers not representing any particular carriers primarily engaged as independent contractors in the sale or placement of insurance contracts with carriers, but not employees of the insurance carriers they represent. This industry also includes independent organizations concerned with insurance services.

    Show More
  8. Zippia Score 4.1

    Company Description:

    Overmyer Hall Associates is the leading commercial and personal lines independent insurance broker in Central Ohio. Headquartered in Columbus, OH.

  9. Zippia Score 3.9

    Company Highlights:

    Integrity offers customizable home, auto, business and life insurance throughout Iowa, Minnesota and Wisconsin. Together with partner Grange Insurance – a 13 state enterprise – we’re rated an “A” (Excellent) from A.M. Best and have $2 billion in assets. Integrity has the strength and stability of a large insurance carrier but with the local, personalized service of a small company.

    Show More
  10. Zippia Score 3.9

    Company Description:

    We're a leading digital insurance marketplace of 40+ A-rated home and auto carriers.

  11. Zippia Score 3.8

    Company Description:

    Assurex Global is an exclusive Partnership of the most prominent independent agents and brokers in the world. Assurex Global is the world's largest privately held commercial insurance, risk management, and employee benefits brokerage group. Assurex Global's combination of local expertise and global reach helps you navigate the changing insurance landscape with confidence.

    Show More
  12. Zippia Score 3.8

    Company Description:

    While at a large CPA firm, Doug was often troubled that only the very large companies could afford his services. He always thought that with lower overhead, the same quality of knowledge and level...

    Show More
  13. Zippia Score 3.7

    Company Description:

    Partner Platform agency management system has built-in Insurance CRM, Insurance Trust Accounting, Text Messaging, Mobile App, & Insurance Agency Websites

  14. Zippia Score 3.7

    Company Description:

    QuickInsured operates as an independent insurance agency, licensed in all 50 states. We work with the nation's top-rated insurance carriers to provide a comprehensive and customized solution for our client's home, auto, life, and commercial insurance needs.

    Show More
  15. Zippia Score 3.6

    Company Description:

    INSURANCE BENEFIT PROGRAMS: ACCIDENT, LIFE AND HEALTH BENEFITS PAID TO MEMBERS

  16. Zippia Score 3.6

    Company Description:

    We promote, progress & protect the professional advice and guidance only independent insurance agents provide.

  17. Zippia Score 3.3

Other national companies with offices in Columbus, OH

Zippia Score 4.9

Company Description:

AXA is a French multinational insurance firm headquartered in the 8th arrondissement of Paris that engages in global insurance, investment management, and other financial services.

Show More
What people like about AXA:

Great colleagues and challenging work environement.

Zippia Score 4.8

Company Description:

American Life Insurance Company provides multinational life insurance to consumers and businesses worldwide. It offers individual products, such as health and life insurance, savings, accident insurance, retirement planning, and travel insurance; business products, including credit insurance, pensions, and employee benefits; wealth management solutions. The company offers its products through agents, brokers, and financial institutions. It was formerly known as Asia Life Insurance Company and changed its name to American Life Insurance Company in 1951. The company was founded in 1921 and is based in Wilmington, Delaware. As of August 1, 2012, American Life Insurance Company operates as a subsidiary of MetLife, Inc.

Show More

Zippia Score 4.8

Company Highlights:

AmWINS is the largest specialty distributor of property, casualty and professional lines insurance products such as public entities, construction risks. Their sales professionals are strategically located throughout the United States to service retail agents with innovative excess & surplus (E&S) lines and specialty insurance solutions.

Show More
What people like about AmWINS Group:

Flexibility and the company culture. They truly value their employees

Zippia Score 4.8

Company Description:

The Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) preserves and promotes public confidence in the U.S. financial system by insuring depositors for at least $250,000 per insured bank; by identifying, monitoring and addressing risks to the deposit insurance funds; and by limiting the effect on the economy and the financial system when a bank or thrift institution fails. The FDIC Board of Directors is comprised of a chairman, vice chairman and FDIC director, as well as the Comptroller of the Currency and the head of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. The FDIC publishes their budget, strategic plans, and financial reports on an annual or quarterly basis. The Annual Reports page contains the yearly accomplishments of the corporation, and has each report available from 1996 to the present. FDIC runs and office of international affairs, considering technical assistance programs, foreign visitor and secondment programs, foreign examiner training programs, international leadership development programs, and FDIC subject matter experts participate as keynote speakers, panel members and facilitators for numerous international organizations' conferences, symposia and seminars. The FDIC was established in 1933 in response to the thousands of bank failures that occurred in the 1920s and early 1930s.

Show More
What people like about Federal Deposit Insurance:

Work with very smart people, great facilities, good pay and great benefits.

Zippia Score 4.8

Company Description:

Zurich Insurance Group Ltd is a Swiss insurance company, headquartered in Zürich, and the country's largest insurer.

What people like about Zurich:

Approach towards work is excellent. There will be a constant support from the team to think out of the box

Zippia Score 4.7

Company Highlights:

Founded in 2004, Anthem Inc. has been the largest for-profit managed health care company in the Blue Cross and Blue Shield Association. Headquartered in Indianapolis, Indiana, Anthem, Inc. delivers a number of leading health benefit solutions through a broad portfolio of integrated health care plans and related services. This American health insurance company also offers specialty products such as life and disability insurance benefits, dental, vision, behavioral health benefit services, and more.

Show More
What people like about Elevance Health:

I like the fact that Anthem does have managers that are human and you can talk with them.

Zippia Score 4.6

Company Description:

Willis of New York, Inc. offers general insurance products and services. The company is based in New York, New York. Willis of New York, Inc. operates as a subsidiary of Willis Of Michigan, Inc.

Show More

Zippia Score 4.6

Company Highlights:

Hylant is one of the largest privately held insurance brokerage firms in the US Hylant offers complete risk management services, employee benefits consultation, wellness strategies, loss control, healthcare management and a wide array of insurance solutions for both businesses and individuals. The company has 14 offices in Ohio, Michigan, Illinois, Indiana, Florida and Tennessee with more than 650 professionals on staff.

Show More

Zippia Score 4.6

Company Description:

The Allstate Corporation protects people from life's uncertainties with more than 113 million proprietary policies. Allstate offers a broad array of protection products through multiple brands and diverse distribution channels, including auto, home, life and other insurance offered through its Allstate, Esurance, Encompass, SquareTrade and Answer Financial brands.

Show More
What people like about Allstate:

Work/Life Balance; Continuing Education; Career Development; Merit Awards; Home Based Worker; Work Flexibility; Opportunities

Zippia Score 4.6

Company Description:

National General Management Corp. operates as a property and casualty insurance company in the United States. The company offers auto and RV insurance, which covers bodily injury liability, property damage liability, personal liability, collision, medical payments, comprehensive, uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage, and personal injury protection. It also provides home insurance, including homeowners, renters, condominiums, and specialized homeowners coverage; commercial vehicle insurance; and motorcycle and boat insurance. The company serves individual consumers, automotive dealerships, and other businesses. National General Management Corp. offers its products and services through a network of claims professionals and local independent agents. National General Management Corp. was formerly known as GMAC Insurance Management Corporation and changed its name to National General Management Corp. in July 2013. The company was incorporated in 1989 and is based in Winston-Salem, North Carolina with additional offices in the United States and Canada. It also has operations in Europe, Latin America, and Asia. National General Management Corp. operates as a subsidiary of National General Holdings Corp.

Show More

Zippia Score 4.6

Company Description:

Erie Insurance offers a range of services to meet family insurance needs, including a variety of home and tenant (renters) insurance policies and boat insurance. ERIE also offers a variety of business insurance products to meet the needs of both small and large businesses. Erie Family Life offers a complete line of products to meet individual and business life insurance needs. When H.O. Hirt and O.G. Crawford decided to start an insurance exchange in 1925, they wanted to base it on “simple common sense, mixed with just plain decency.” They turned to the Golden Rule as a guiding principle: “Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.” The two entrepreneurs spent months drumming up support for the Erie Insurance Exchange, with nothing but their axiom and a business plan scribbled on a 10-cent tablet. On April 20, 1925, their fundraising concluded and 90 years of service and innovation began.

Show More
What people like about Erie Insurance:

They train well and advance within. There are a lot of opportunities available.

Zippia Score 4.5

Company Description:

Centene Corporation is at the forefront of providing quality health access for individuals across the United States, including those who are under-insured and uninsured. As a leading multi-national healthcare enterprise, Centene is dedicated to transforming the health of communities we serve by providing local services for the families and individuals in our care. In 1984, Centene Corporation was founded as Family Hospital Physician Associates, a nonprofit health plan in Milwaukee, WI, by Elizabeth “Betty” Brinn. As the company grew, Michael Neidorff joined as Centene's President and Chief Executive Officer in 1996, helping to establish the new name and move its headquarters in St. Louis, MO. By the early 2000s, Centene's positive impact on healthcare spurred additional health plans, significant growth in revenue, and its transformation into a publicly traded company. After joining the FORTUNE 500 list in 2010, Centene continued to expand by launching operations in correctional healthcare, commercial insurance, and coverage for the military community, while acquiring large companies like Health Net and WellCare. As the #1 U.S. insurer in the Health Insurance Marketplace, Centene has never lost its focus on individual care or its passion toward community health. The company currently provides coverage across the United States and internationally in Spain, Slovakia, and the UK. With local health plans all over the U.S., staying connected with those individuals and families that need care most is central to Centene's unwavering commitment to quality healthcare for everyone.

Show More
What people like about Centene:

I have been working for Centene for over years. I started out as an Basic Claim Analyst to now an Advanced Claims Analyst. There is potential growth working for Centene Corporation.

Zippia Score 4.3

Company Description:

Dawson Companies is an insurance agency, provides insurance products and services. It offers business insurance for community associations, equine and farm owners, financial institutions, jewelers, manufacturers, non-profits companies, pharmacies/pharmaceuticals, and restaurants; and construction, environmental, healthcare, management liability, medical malpractice, mining, moving and storage, professional, retail, transportation, and technology industries.

Show More

Zippia Score 4.2

Company Highlights:

Investors Title has built its business and reputation on responsiveness and efficiency, a deep knowledge of the real estate industry, and long-lasting relationships with its partners and customers. What they do, they do well: residential and commercial title insurance and innovative business solutions for their partners.

Show More

Zippia Score 4.2

Company Description:

Founded in 1893, Oswald advisers deliver the full range of insurance brokerage and risk management services. Learn more and connect today.

Zippia Score 4.1

Company Description:

Kansas City Life Insurance Company is a public insurance company established in 1895 and located in Kansas City, Missouri. The company's 1,400 agents market individual life, annuity and group products through agencies located in 48 US states and the District of Columbia.

Show More

Zippia Score 4.0

Company Description:

The Kemper family of companies is one of the nation's leading insurers. With $8 billion in assets, Kemper is improving the world of insurance by offering personalized solutions for individuals, families and businesses. Kemper's businesses collectively: - Offer insurance for home, auto, life, health and valuables - Service six million policies - Are represented by more than 20,000 independent agents and brokers - Employ 6,000 associates dedicated to providing exceptional service - Are licensed to sell insurance in 50 states and the District of Columbia

Show More

Zippia Score 3.7

Company Description:

E&S Insurance Co.

Zippia Score 3.6

Company Description:

Central writes over 350,000 home, auto and business insurance policies in 20 states. They are represented by your local independent agent and your agent's expertise, matched with Central's innovative products and outstanding service, has satisfied clients' needs for over 140 years.

Show More

Best insurance companies in Columbus, OH

RankCompanyZippia Score
1State Auto Insurance4.8
2Root Insurance4.8
3Motorists Mutual Insurance Co4.7
4SafeAuto4.4
5Safelite Solutions4.3
6International Risk Consultants4.1
7Overmyer Hall Associates4.1
8Integrity Insurance3.9
9Matic3.9
10Assurex Global3.8
11ROOT & CO. CPAS3.8
12Strategic Insurance Software3.7
13QuickInsured3.7
14United Commercial Travelers3.6
15Ohio Insurance Agents Association3.6
16Monk's Copy Shop3.3